Indian media gives homegrown Ola a better ride than Uber

App based car ride services such as Uber and Ola Cabs certainly grab headlines in India. The under 30 co-founders of Ola, recently made it to the richest Indian list and this week Chinese taxi hailing firm, Didi Kuaid, invested in Ola Cabs.

A study by CARMA International, on the media sentiment around app based cabs, across July and August, 2015 shows Ola Cabs faired better for volume of mentions (58% Share of Voice ), but more importantly  had stronger favorability rating (50 rating). Faced with the issue of women safety, Uber cornered 42% of SoV with 46 favorability rating, which CARMA rates as unfavorable.

Ola  Cabs also had a better media IQ score than Uber. CARMA rates its Media IQ  score that shows PR impact based on volume of coverage, favourability and impressions as -60.66, better than a sharply weak Media IQ (-281.66) for Uber. Both companies, however, remain in the negative IQ zone :

Issues around Uber and Ola

The break up of issues around Uber and Ola shows that the media reported positively on customer convenience, even as security and regulatory concerns dominate negative comments :

News Sources for Ola and Uber

Positive influencers

The report also analyzed the sources of positive and negative news about Ola and Uber. Positive sentiment, quite naturally, came from company spokespersons and partners who defended the brands.

Two-thirds of the comments from think tanks were favorable for the ride sharing industry. For instance, Kartik Hosanagar, a professor at the Wharton Business School said, "Uber has certainly raised the bar for transport companies around the world” (Economic Times, 31 July, 2015).

Surprisingly, even though customer convenience made up 49% of the positive messaging, customers do not dominate media influencers for the two brands.

Negative Influencers

Proving once again that the Government is the biggest operating environment for any business, government officials were the most vocal and largely unfavorable set of influencers (144 unfavorable comments). Nearly three-fourth of their comments incriminated the app based cab services on a range of issues including use of diesel vehicles in Delhi, legal cases, safety of women and non-compliance of other transport rules.

Obviously enough, trade and business associations representing the taxi industry and regulators were clearly influencers who did not put forward a single positive comment for the app based cab services companies.